The “buzzard signal fly”

Waterberg RangeDuring our time at Geelhoutbos farm in South Africa’s Northern (now Limpopo) Province, we spent most of our time in the foothills below a magnificent north-facing escarpment of the Waterberg Mountain Range. We were here to collect Buprestidae (including the magnificent Evides, featured previously in this post), and it was in the low bushveld woodland where the greatest diversity of buprestids would be found. Many of the buprestids we encountered were associated with the acacias that abundantly dotted the landscape – especially the iconic “umbrella thorn” (Acacia tortilis) and “sweet thorn” (Acacia karoo), providing sustenance for everything from bitsy beetles (including our beloved buprestids) to giant giraffes. Still, I kept eyeing the mountains, yearning to clamber up on top of the billion year old massif for no other reason than because it was there. Chuck had the good sense to stay down below amongst the acacias and buprestids while I spent an afternoon winding my way up the escarpment in the company of our hostess, Susan Strauss. I didn’t collect many buprestids during that trek, and if success is measured solely by numbers of buprestids collected then Chuck won. But if success also includes the chance to see spectacularly endless vistas from an otherworldly landscape on a once in a lifetime trip, then I didn’t do too badly.

Bromophila caffra

While I didn’t see many buprestids during that afternoon, I did see a few other insects interesting enough to attract my attention and maybe an attempt at a photo. This stunning fly was one of those insects. Even though it exceeded a full inch in length, it still wasn’t the largest fly I had ever seen. However, with its black body, metallic blue wings and large, round, wax-red head it was certainly among the most impressive. A quick scan through my recently acquired Field Guide to Insects of South Africa (Picker et al. 2002) has at last identified this fly as Bromophila caffra. It is a member of the family Platystomatidae, commonly known as signal flies and part of the great superfamily Tephritoidea of fruit fly fame (i.e., true fruit flies – not “the” fruit fly which belongs to the family Drosophilidae and which are more properly called vinegar flies).

Signal flies are interesting on several fronts, firstly because of their catholic tastes – Sivinski (1999) records rotting tree trunks, bulbs, roots and fruit, dried flowers and dead grass stems, dung and fungus as breeding sites, and notes – gruesomely – that mass graves dug in World War II sometimes produced huge numbers of the species Platystoma lugubre. It is some of the Australasian species, however, that have truly made a name for this family. In the tropical rainforests of Guinea and Queensland, males of many species exhibit modifications of their heads that are used in agonistic interactions with sexual rivals. These vary from broadening of the face into a surface used to push against the face of another male, to extremely well-developed stalk eyes used to gauge rival male’s size and strength in face to face combat.

But what about Bromophila caffra? Aside from being one of the most recognizable of flies in Africa, it’s sluggish disposition and apparent noxiousness were obvious even to early naturalists. Marshall (1902) noted the similarity of its coloration (black body, blue wings, red or yellow head) to that of two Pompilus spp. and one sphecid wasp with which it occurred sympatrically. Regarding its habits, he also noted:

The Bromophila fly is very plentiful; it is the most sluggish fly known to me, and settles about on trees and bushes in a very conspicuous manner. It ejects a yellow liquid from the mouth when handled, and was refused when offered to my baboons and Cercopithecus monkey.

Andrew Whittington, commenting on a photo of this species posted on DipteraInfo.com, provides further clues that seem to confirm the noxious qualities of this species, explaining not only its striking color and brazen habits but also the ease with which I obtained the above photograph:

Our knowledge of larval habits is very rudimentary. There appears to be an association with the roots of Terminalia trees (Combretaceae), from which the larvae sequester various toxic compounds (probably cyclic triterpenes) possibly for defense. This may render the adults toxic too, as a defense against predation – not a thoroughly tested hypothesis.
Adults are slow moving and ponderous … and photogenic!

I find it surprising that a large, strikingly distinctive, abundant insect such as Bromophila caffra should lack a common name, but it appears this is the case. None was given in Field Guide to Insects of South Africa, nor amongst the several South African wildlife and dipteran websites which I encountered featuring photos of this insect. In thinking about what common name Bromophila caffra could have, I can’t help but draw comparisons between this insect and the turkey vulture (Cathartes aura), or “buzzard,” of North America (despite their belonging to entirely separate phyla). Both species are among the larger members of their respective orders and make their living eating repulsive foodstuffs. Hulking black with naked, red, plastic-like heads, most predators regard them as too vile and noxious to bother with, leaving them free to pass their lives in unmolested disdain. With this in mind, I hereby propose “buzzard signal fly” as the official common name for this insect ;-)

Additional photographs of Bromophila caffra can be seen at Joan Young’s fine blog, South African Photographs, and at Biodiversty Explorer, the web of life in Southern Africa. This is the fifth in a series of posts covering a natural history excursion to South Africa in November/December 1999. Click on “South Africa” under “Tags” to see links and summaries for other posts in this series.

REFERENCES:

Marshall, G. A. K. 1902. Five year’s observations and experiments (1896-1901) on the bionomics of South African insects, chiefly directed to the investigation of mimicry and warning colours. Transactions of the Entomological Society of London, 1902:287-584.

Picker, M., C. Griffiths and A. Weaving. 2002. Field Guide to Insects of South Africa. Struik Publishers, Cape Town, 444 pp.

Sivinski, J. 1999. Breeding habits and sex in families closely related to Tephritidae: Opportunities for comparative studies of the evolution of fruit fly behavior, pp. 23-39. In: M. Aluja and A. L. Norrbom [eds.], Fruit Flies (Tephritidae): Phylogeny and Evolution of Behavior, CRC Press, Boca Raton, 984 pp.

About Ted C. MacRae

Ted C. MacRae is a research entomologist by vocation and beetle taxonomist by avocation. Areas of expertise in the latter include worldwide jewel beetles (Buprestidae) and North American longhorned beetles (Cerambycidae). More recent work has focused on North American tiger beetles (Cicindelidae) and their distribution, ecology, and conservation.
This entry was posted in Diptera, Platystomatidae and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

13 Responses to The “buzzard signal fly”

  1. Anonymous says:

    This is such an interesting read. The common name fits perfectly. Is there a fly-naming standards committee for common names for flies?

  2. Hugh says:

    What a remarkable insect. A plastic toy version of it would look exactly like it.

  3. This looks like one I recocognise. :) I like the additional info you have here Ted and it fits very well with the common name you proposed. I thought it looked vulture or buzzard like myself. Do you think it might be the red color which makes predators avoid them?

    Thanks so much for the reference to my post too. I enjoyed reading this.

  4. Anon – there is a Common Names Committee for North American insects coordinated by the ESA (Entomological Society of America) – I presume there may be something analogous for Africa but do not know that for a fact, nor do I know if there is an overall fly naming body. Alas, my proposal would probably be considered too tongue-in-cheek to receive serious consideration.

    Joan – predators avoid them because of the noxious secretions they emit when disturbed. The red head fits a general pattern of bright, contrasting colors (usually involving black and red/yellow/orange) exhibited by noxious/venomous insects to advertise their defensive capabilities to those would-be predators that have already learned their lesson – those that haven’t and who try to make a meal of the fly will soon be educated. It’s a strikingly beautiful example of what is called aposematic (warning) coloration – along the same lines as the tyrant ground beetles I discussed in my previous post.

  5. Lesley Dewar says:

    http://buildyourtraffic.wordpress.com/2009/01/16/lesson-3-build-your-list-part-one/

    I found you on Alpha Inventions and we have some great ideas on what makes it work, better.

    Come visit.

  6. Lesley Dewar says:

    Thanks for visiting my site. You might enjoy a story I wrote about Australian flies – some years ago. Here’s the link

    http://notallpoppies.wordpress.com/the-idler-the-idle-thoughts-of-an-idle-mind/where-have-all-my-spiders-gone/

    or the short version: http://is.gd/gmP7

    I hope you like it. I have certainly liked reading your articles.

    Cheers
    Lesley

  7. Leslie – thanks for the links, I enjoyed the articles very much.
    regards–ted

  8. myrmecos says:

    Now that’s a fly.

  9. okathleen says:

    Intriguing stuff, it’s a jungle out there…
    http://www.okathleen.wordpress.com

  10. DougT says:

    Cool fly. The Waterberg Mountain Range looks remarkably like the Atascosas in southeastern arizona.

  11. Lesley Dewar says:

    G’day Ted.

    I am still at it – try to think of a whale as a rather large water beetle :-)

    This was my first time at the Perth Writer’s Festival and I just loved it! Chris Pash’s workshop and his book The Last Whale have made a great impact on me, both from learning about how to write non fiction and an objective view of why and how whaling can and should be stopped.

    I think this should be a standard history / sociology text book in our schools.

    http://notallpoppies.wordpress.com/

    Cheers
    Lesley

  12. Guinevere.S says:

    i knew, i knew that mountain!!!!! ha ha its the farm next to ours its a beautiful area :)

Commentaria

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s